Meanign transi

Mostly for counter cultural reasons contrarian tankie alt right [i.e to rebel against our lean left societal norms, I am pro Transgender]) M2F must fall into three or more of these categories below and F2M must fall into two or more categories below (mostly for counter cultural reasons [i.e to rebel against our lean left societal norms, I am pro Transgender]) to get their rights and to be recognized as their new gender/sex: (note 1):

1) They truly defy traditional gender roles and in a way that won’t get harmed by the patriarchy, mens liberation concern

2) they are Intersex also some trans say they are all intersex 

3) have X, XXY, XXY or XXXY chromosome(s), or would have had this chromosome in the most realistic reality where they were born in that reality 

4) they had at least one past life (or will have at least one future life) where they spent their entire life in that past or future life(s) as the gender that they changed to in this life, 

5) they have one or more Personality disorders (any type) and can't get cured

6) God considered making them the gender that they changed to but didn't, 

7) they have a masculine-athletic phenotype (if biologically female)/they have a feminine-non athletic phenotype (if biologically male), 

8) if they don't get their rights, they'll still get around not having said rights which would be pretty much the same thing as them having those rights, 

9) they have a twin sibling who was born as the opposite biological sex of the biological sex that said transgender persons were born as

10) God would say that they really were born as the wrong gender,

11) if at least 75+ percent of anti transgender people from the last 100 years agree or would agree that said transgender persons are really the gender they changed to (and at least 10 of the remaining 25 percent are either neutral, apolitical, indifferent or mixed on that)

12) when the transgender persons parents were pregnant with them, the doctor made a mistake and wrongly told their parents that the child (the transgender persons) would be a biological sex that said transgender persons were not born as (but ended up being the same gender that the transgender person changed to after birth)

13) they were a tomboy or femgirl in their childhood as the gender they were born as 

14) They perform their desired gender (not essentialist) per Gender voluntarism

15) They are Body Positive

16) They are a HSTS Transgender (M2F) female/woman  (ovarit is luke warm on that)

17) They are a girlfag or guydyke

18)  *They are AFAB non-dysphorics of a wide variety*

19A) If they don’t meet that criteria, I privately and off the record feel people need to get Transgender people to compromise on the Transgender issue where both sides are happy with the compromise for Transgender people who don't meet the above criteria (joe biden ‘no compromise on trans rights) Jan 2020 tweet  note 1

Privately and off the record I feel that ,transgender people who do not meet my requirements above and don’t compromise, until this type of natural sex gender changing surgery become legal for humans (and they use that to change gender/sex) or until we abolish our Cissexist patriarchy, privately and off the record  ,transgender people who do not meet my requirements above and don’t compromise, until this type of natural sex gender changing surgery become legal for humans (and they use that to change gender/sex) or until we abolish our Cissexist patriarchy, Personally I am other side political post position on those Transgender people who do not meet my above requirements   note 1

*Thats because inclus people use TERF arguments themselves.

No, really.

A lot of hardcore inclus/pro-xeno/pro-neo/non-dysphoric arguments are straight up transphobia imho.

Ever heard gender is a social construct? It gets not only used to justify so much BS, like choosing to be trans, that gender is whatever you want it to be, that being trans is really really cool, that people should be recruited into it, that you can just choose labels because they make you feel "comfy" and words dont have meaning anyway, that only society needs to change and accept trans people to "make us better" (as in fix our dysphoria without medical transition) kinda like overweight people just want to define beauty rather than lose weight, and a ton of other stuff, but in reality all that undermines dysphoric trans people who CANT choose and are stuck being trans and absolutely NEED to medically transition to even have a life worth speaking of.

Apart from being wrapped in a pro-trans tunic its essentially the same thing as TERFs saying being trans is a choice, a trend people just hop on to, that trans people erode the meaning of words like "woman" and "man", that we dont need transition etc. the only difference being that TERFs argue that from the standpoint of "biological reality" (aka youll always be your biological sex) and that evil evil "men" get into womens restrooms and other safe spaces.

I just wanted to give an example here, not an exhaustive list, but if anyone wants to add some other examples I wont be offended. Its just amazing how well just this alone plays into TERF rhetoric, how transphobic these supposedly pro-trans arguments become when you deconstruct them with a focus on how they apply (or rather dont) to dysphoric trans people.

The other reason why mainstream (as in inclus) trans spaces dont attack TERFs much is because TERFs and inclus people arent enemies. Most inclus people are AFAB non-dysphorics of a wide variety that TERFs need not care about because they dont invade womens restrooms, so TERFs arent a threat to being pupgender gendervoid whatever mountain of labels you want.

Who is a threat to those people is transmeds, because we actually have the most problems because of the commodification of transness, its transformation into this benign fashion choice, aesthetic and so forth, because 80% of inclus rhetoric shoots us dysphoric people in the foot, and about the same amount of inclus people hurt our reputation by being absolutely vile whenever someone isnt 110% pro their flavor of trans, pizzagender, recugender and all, and that hurts our public image, too.

People IRL are afraid of trans people like me. Like most dysphorics, Im perfectly chill when people slip up, but people constantly bite their tongues around me and stumble over themselves with a dozen apologies at once over every mistake because they are just afraid that Ill blow up at them if they dare offend me in the slightest. That kind of thing might be a nice feeling for a narcissist or something, but to me its just in the way of genuinely connecting with people honesttransgender reddit

OR

19B) If they don't meet that criteria they should be able to be recognized as Trans and get their rights if they can convince a Judge they are Trans the same way that Kris Kringle and his lawyer in Miracle on 34th Street (1947 film) convinced the court he was the one true Santa Claus  (but it would be as easy to convince said Judge they are Trans as it was easy for Kris Kringle and his lawyer to convince his Judge that he was the one true Santa Claus)

To me there is as much ambiguity as whether such Trans people are really the gender they identify as as there is ambiguity of whether Kris Kringle in Miracle on 34th Street (1947) is really Santa Claus (meshes with private blog view trans are mentally ill)

Some of my other private and off the record views on Transgenderism can be found here